Short answer: The Lab Score is a 0 to 10 rating of how well a tool runs a real yoga studio. YSMS Lab earns the right to give it by testing every tool on the same model studio. We score 61 features and 4 experience areas against fixed rules, do the math in code, and take no vendor money.

FactYSMS Lab method
Method version3.0 (November 2026)
Tools scored7
Test setup1 model studio: 140 members, 12 teachers, 32 classes a week
What we score10 weighted parts: 61 feature items plus 4 experience scores
Score scale0 to 10, one decimal, rounded once at the end
Hard caps3 (billing errors, data held back, costly or slow exit)
Coverage100% for all 7 tools
Vendor moneyNone. No affiliate links, paid placements or sponsored reviews.
Key facts about the YSMS Lab method

What is the difference between the Lab Score and the Owner Score?

YSMS Lab publishes two scores and never blends them. The Lab Score comes from our own hands-on tests. The Owner Score will come from verified studio owners who use each tool.

Lab ScoreOwner Score
Who gives itYSMS Lab Test Team, using fixed rules and one test studioVerified studio owners who use the tool
Scale0 to 10, one decimal1 to 5, median shown with the range
Drives our verdictYesNo. It sits beside the Lab Score.
When it showsOn every tool we reviewOnly after 30 or more verified owners respond
TodayPublished for 7 toolsNot published yet. The owner survey has not opened.
RefreshFull re-test every 12 monthsPublished once a year, collected all year
Two scores, side by side, never averaged together

The two scores are never averaged into one number. Owner survey answers are not allowed as inputs to the Lab Score. When the two scores disagree, the review will say so in one line.

What studio do you test every tool on?

Every tool is tested on the same model studio: one location, 140 members and 12 teachers. Using one setup means every tool faces the same jobs, so the scores can be compared fairly.

Part of the studioOur test setup
Studio1 location, 2 rooms (1 heated, with 24 mat spots)
Members140: 90 on memberships, 40 on class packs, 10 on an intro offer
Teachers12, on 4 pay rules: flat per class, per head, base plus per head above 8, and a share of revenue
Schedule32 group classes a week, with privates from 3 teachers
Offers14-day intro offer, unlimited membership, 10-class pack, a bundle of classes plus 1 private a month, a sliding scale community class
Programs6-week series. Weekend workshop with a guest teacher on a revenue split. 200-hour teacher training: 12 trainees, a deposit and 6 installments. 1 retreat.
Multi-locationA second test location, where the vendor allows it
The YSMS Lab model studio

This setup matches the owner we write for most: an established studio with one location that runs teacher trainings. We test each tool on the plan a studio like this would buy, and we record which plan that was.

What do you score, and how much does each part count?

The Lab Score has 10 weighted parts that add up to 100%. Memberships and billing, and price and contract terms, count the most, at 14% each.

PartWhat we checkWeightWhy this weight
1ADaily scheduling10%Owners use it every day. It is rarely why they leave, so it is not higher.
1BSeries, workshops and teacher trainings10%Trainings are a major revenue line for yoga studios. One owner says they bring in about $25,000 every 3 to 4 months.
2Memberships, class packs and billing14%This is how a studio earns money every day. Bundles, intro offers and autopay decide income.
3Client app and booking experience8%Members complain about booking steps and extra accounts, but owners rarely switch over it.
4Reporting and growth tools8%Intro offer conversion is the number coaches say matters most. Owners rarely complain about reports.
5Teacher management and pay8%Yoga pay rules, such as base plus per head, are complex and easy to get wrong.
6Support quality and reliability12%Slow support is the top complaint about newer tools. Outages and billing errors count here.
7Migration and onboarding8%Switching is where owner reviews turn from praise to complaints.
8Data ownership and export8%Owners want control of their client data, and some report unclear ownership and export fees.
9Price and contract terms14%Contracts and cancellation are the strongest owner complaint we found.
Total100%
The 10 weighted parts of the Lab Score

Parts 1A to 5 are features and make up 58% of the score. Parts 6 to 9 are the experience of using the tool and make up 42%. That split is why a tool with many features can still score lower than a simpler one.

What research set these weights?

Owner complaints set the weights. We read owner reviews and complaint records on October 28, 2026, and ranked each source by how direct it was. This research shaped the weights. It is not scoring data.

TierSourceHow we used it
AOwner reviews on Capterra and G2, and BBB complaintsMain evidence for the weights
BReddit owner threads, seen through a vendor roundupA strong pointer, not a neutral summary
CBusiness coaches and podcasts, mostly hosted by vendorsWeak evidence
DVendor marketingContext only. Never used to support a weight.
How we weighted the evidence behind the weights

What owners complain about most, strongest first:

  • Contracts and cancellation. On Capterra, the cancellation theme in Mindbody reviews is 89% negative across 142 reviews. This is why part 9 carries 14%.
  • Billing errors. Owners report wrong charges and bugs left unfixed. This feeds part 6 and hard cap H1.
  • Real total cost. Owners describe costs that rise through add-ons and fees. This feeds part 9.
  • Support when something breaks. Slow replies are the most common complaint about newer tools. This is why part 6 carries 12%.
  • Switching and data. Owners report unclear data ownership and export fees. This feeds parts 7 and 8, and caps H2 and H3.
  • Too many features and booking friction. This feeds parts 1A and 3.

Review counts on Capterra vary a lot by vendor, from about 2,990 for Mindbody to 26 for Walla (October 2026). So star averages are never used in any score.

Research sources (read October 28, 2026):

How do you score features?

Every feature item gets one of 5 scores: 10, 7, 5, 3 or 0. The same rubric applies to every item and every tool.

Parts 1A to 5 hold 61 feature items. Each one is a specific job a studio needs done. One asks: “Can one pack cover group classes and private sessions?” Another asks: “Can a training be sold with a deposit and automatic installments?” Each item lists its requirements. R1 is the core requirement.

ScoreWhat it means
10Native feature. Every requirement works on the tested plan, in the normal workflow.
7Native feature with one requirement missing. Or everything works, but only with a paid add-on or a higher plan.
5The core requirement works, but 2 or more others are missing. Or an add-on with any requirement missing.
3Only by workaround: manual steps every time, a spreadsheet, a support ticket or a separate paid tool.
0Not offered, or the core requirement fails. A “coming soon” feature scores 0.
The feature rubric, the same for all 61 items

A tester can reach an item score in 3 ways. They can tick the requirements they saw working, set a quick score directly, or leave the item blank if they don’t know. A quick score overrides the ticks. A blank is skipped, never counted as 0.

Each part’s score is the average of its items. 56 of the 61 items count toward the overall Lab Score. The other 5 are tested and scored, but they feed other results:

  • 4 multi-location items feed the score for brands with 2 or more locations.
  • 1 hot yoga item, spot booking in a heated room, answers our hot yoga question.
PartItems testedCount toward the Lab Score
1A Daily scheduling97
1B Series, workshops and teacher trainings1010
2 Memberships, class packs and billing1413
3 Client app and booking experience88
4 Reporting and growth tools1211
5 Teacher management and pay87
Total6156
Feature items per part

Which 8 items count double?

8 key items count double inside their part, because each one ties to how a yoga studio earns money or where errors cost the most.

ItemKey itemPart
1.13Training application and approval1B
1.14Deposits and payment plans1B
1.16Contact hours tracking1B
2.1Bundles across service types2
2.3Intro offers2
3.1First booking as a new client3
4.1Intro offer conversion report4
5.1Pay rule set, checked against our own hand calculation5
The 8 key items

How do you score support, migration, data export and price?

Each of these 4 parts gets one whole score from 0 to 10, matched to written levels. YSMS Lab sets each score from live testing and expert knowledge, including feedback from studios that used the tool in the last 12 months.

PartWhat we testA 10 looks likeA 5 looks likeA 0 looks like
6 Support and reliability3 timed tickets (a how-to, a billing question and an urgent “clients can’t book”), sent on a weekday and a weekend. Outages and billing errors logged.A human answers urgent issues within 1 business hour, weekends included. No outages in our test.Replies take 1 to 2 business days. Some wrong answers. Occasional outages.No human support you can reach, or a critical outage left for more than a day.
7 Migration and onboardingA test move using a sample export, the vendor’s written plan, time to go live and staff learning time.Free migration. Everything moves, including stored cards and pack balances. Live within 14 days.Partial move, a lot of cleanup, or migration costs extra.No migration help, or data can’t be imported.
8 Data ownership and exportThe contract clause, our own export file with record counts and the card release policy.The contract says the studio owns its data. Full self-serve export. Stored cards released free.Core records only, and only through support. Card release limited.The vendor claims your client data, or refuses a full export.
9 Price and contract termsThe pricing model, contract terms, fees and add-ons.Month-to-month. No setup fee. Cancel by email. No yoga essentials locked to top plans.Quote only or many add-ons. 12-month auto-renewal. Early termination fee.Misleading terms, or charges after you cancel.
How the 4 experience parts are scored

Scores between levels, such as a 6, are allowed. Three things are never used as inputs: Owner Score survey answers, review-site star averages and vendor marketing claims.

Whether a vendor publishes its prices does not change the Lab Score. Real costs and published prices are covered in our guide to the cost of software for yoga studios.

What are hard caps, and why do you use them?

A hard cap is a ceiling. A tool with a serious problem can’t score above it, however good its features are.

CapWhen it appliesHighest possible score
H1 Billing integrityAny one of these: we reproduce a wrong charge in our test studio. We are charged after cancelling our own account. Or 2 or more studios report the same billing error in the last 12 months, and it is still not fixed.6.9
H2 Data held backThe contract gives the vendor ownership of studio client data, or the vendor refuses a full client export5.9
H3 Costly or slow exitA full export costs a fee, takes more than 14 days, or stored cards can’t be moved to another payment processor7.9
The 3 hard caps

A cap is off unless it applies. If more than one applies, the lowest cap wins. Caps also apply to every category score for that tool. Each review states any cap and its reason in one line.

Caps protect owners from the 3 problems that hurt studios most in our research: billing errors, locked-in data and a hard exit. A 6.9 or 5.9 cap keeps a tool out of the Good band. A 7.9 cap keeps it just below Good.

What happens when you don’t know something?

Unknown is never scored as zero. If testers don’t know how a feature works, they leave it blank and the item is skipped.

  • A feature that is not offered scores 0. A blank means unknown, never “not offered”.
  • If a whole part is blank, it is left out and the other weights are scaled back up to 100%.
  • Every Lab Score shows its coverage: the share of the method it rests on.
  • A score below 80% coverage is marked provisional, and it is never published as a final ranking.

All 7 tools we have scored have 100% coverage. Every score on the site rests on the full method.

How do you round scores and give badges?

We round once, at the end, to one decimal. A half rounds up, so 7.85 becomes 7.9.

BadgeLab Score
Good8.0 and above
Caution6.0 to 7.9
PoorBelow 6.0
Lab Score badge bands

Part scores on our pages are rounded to one decimal for display only. The math always uses full precision. Order is set by the capped score before rounding, to 2 decimals.

If two tools show the same score at one decimal, the page calls them tied and names the tie-breaker. We break ties with the higher part 9 score, then the higher part 6 score. If they are still tied, they share the place. We never break a tie by choice. No two tools tie in our current results.

How do you pick the 3 category winners?

Test scores guide each category pick, and YSMS Lab makes the final call from hands-on testing. When a winner is not the top score, its page must say why in one line and show the top 3 scores.

CategoryScores it rolls up
Best for independent yoga studios with one or a few locationsNew studio with multiple teachers · Established single-location studio · Ease of daily operations · Data ownership and easy exit · Leaving Mindbody
Best for teacher trainings and workshopsTeacher trainings and workshops
Best for boutique brands expanding to more locationsPremium boutique · Multi-location · Marketing and new clients
The 3 core categories

Here is how a winner is decided:

  1. We compute 9 supporting scores for every tool from its test results. Caps apply to them.
  2. Each category’s roll-up score is the plain average of its supporting scores.
  3. YSMS Lab picks the winner, guided by the roll-up scores and our tests. A winner needs a roll-up score of 6.0 or more.
  4. If the winner is not the top roll-up score, its page says why in one line. The reason cites the test scores that back the pick, and the page shows the top 3 roll-up scores.
  5. If two roll-up scores are within 0.1, the page calls the category close and shows both scores.

The category type is about the kind of business, not the number of sites. Owner-run studios with 2 or 3 sites belong in the first category. Branded boutique studios growing into many sites belong in the third.

In our current results, 2 of the 3 winners are not the top roll-up score, and their pages show why. The winners and their scores are on our best yoga studio software page. Lowest total cost is not a category. It is decided from real costs in our cost guide.

How stable are the results?

Small changes to the weights do not change the top 5 places. We moved each of the 10 weights up and down by 5 points, one at a time, for 20 runs in total.

  • Places 1 to 5 never changed in any run.
  • Only 6th and 7th swapped, in 3 of the 20 runs. Mindbody and Arketa are 0.125 apart, and Mindbody’s place depends on its cap.
  • Across the 20 runs, Walla ranged from 8.27 to 8.46, Momence from 7.85 to 8.20, and Mariana Tek from 7.48 to 7.79.
  • Momence’s Good badge is fragile. At 8.024 it clears 8.0 by 0.024, and it drops below 8.0 in some runs.
  • StudioGrowth is the only tool with 10 on all 4 experience parts. It stays 1st unless those scores average about 7.3 or less.

We ran the same test on the category formulas. 8 of 9 top supporting scores did not change. The multi-location score is close: Walla leads StudioGrowth by 0.14, and it flips to StudioGrowth if either of 2 weights moves by 5 points. Every result here was computed in code from the stored scores, with the method version and date recorded.

Try the Scoring Desk yourself

The Scoring Desk below is a working sample of the tool our testers use. It holds example data for a made-up vendor, not a real tool. Tick a requirement, set a score or turn on a cap, and the Lab Score updates with our real weights and rules.

YSMS Lab · Scoring Desk sample Try the Scoring Desk

This is a working sample of the tool our testers use. Change any score and watch the Lab Score update. It uses the same weights and rules as our real reviews.

Example data for a made-up vendor. The real desk has 61 feature items. This sample shows 2 or 3 per part.

How does the sample vendor score 7.5?

The made-up vendor in the desk scores 7.5, in the Caution band. Here is the same math as a plain table, so you can check it without the desk.

PartWeightPart scoreWeighted points
1A Daily scheduling10%8.50.85
1B Series, workshops and teacher trainings10%6.80.68
2 Memberships, class packs and billing14%8.21.15
3 Client app and booking experience8%10.00.80
4 Reporting and growth tools8%4.30.35
5 Teacher management and pay8%8.30.67
6 Support quality and reliability12%7.00.84
7 Migration and onboarding8%8.00.64
8 Data ownership and export8%9.00.72
9 Price and contract terms14%6.00.84
Total before caps100%7.531
Worked example: the made-up vendor from the desk

No cap applies. The raw score is 7.531. Rounded once, to one decimal, the Lab Score is 7.5.

Weighted points = weight × part score. They are shown to 2 decimals, as on the desk, so they add to 7.54. The total uses full precision, which gives 7.531. That is why we round only once, at the end.

Part scores are rounded for display too. Part 4 shows as 4.3, but its full value is 4.333. Part 5 shows as 8.3, but its full value is 8.333. If you work from the rounded part scores, you get 7.526. The code uses the full values, which gives 7.531. Both round to 7.5.

ItemWhat the tester foundItem scoreCounts
1.10 Multi-session seriesQuick score101
1.14 Deposits and payment plans (key)Every requirement works, but only on an add-on72
1.16 Contact hours tracking (key)2 requirements missing52
How part 1B gets 6.8

Part 1B = (10×1 + 7×2 + 5×2) ÷ 5 = 34 ÷ 5 = 6.8. Key items count 2, so they pull harder on the average.

Item 3.4 is blank in this sample. It is skipped, not scored as 0, so part 3 rests on item 3.1 alone and scores 10.0.

If a cap applied, the result would change like this: H1 would hold the score at 6.9, and H2 at 5.9. H3 would change nothing, because 7.5 is already below 7.9.

These numbers are example data for a made-up vendor. Real Lab Scores are computed in code from stored test results, never by hand.

Which tools have you scored so far?

YSMS Lab has scored 7 tools under method version 3.0, all at 100% coverage. They are listed A to Z here. Each name links to its full review.

ToolLab ScoreBadgeCoverageMethodCaps
Arketa review5.8Poor100%3.0H3 applies. No change, since the score is already below 7.9.
Mariana Tek review7.6Caution100%3.0None
Mindbody review5.9Poor100%3.0Capped at 5.9 (H2, H3). Raw score 6.04.
Momence review8.0Good100%3.0None
StudioGrowth review9.5Good100%3.0None
Walla review8.4Good100%3.0None
WellnessLiving review6.7Caution100%3.0None
Lab Scores, results version 1.1 (November 2026)

Each review shows the plan we tested, the test setup, the test date and who tested it. Scores from different major method versions are never compared directly.

Who is the YSMS Lab Test Team?

The YSMS Lab Test Team is the group of people who test every tool for YSMS Lab. Testing is joint work by many people, so every review carries the team byline, not one person’s name.

How does joint testing work?

  • Every tester works from the same model studio, the same 61 items and the same written levels.
  • The team runs the studio’s real jobs in each tool: building the week, selling packs, paying teachers and moving data in and out.
  • Findings go into the Scoring Desk, which holds one record per tool.
  • Support tickets are timed, and outages and billing errors are logged as they happen.

How are scores agreed?

  • Each item score must match the fixed rubric. Each experience score must match a written level.
  • YSMS Lab reviews the scores for each tool and locks them before anything is published.
  • Code then computes every part score, Lab Score, cap and category score from the locked records.
  • A locked score changes only after a new test, a re-run in code and a new results version.

How do you stay independent?

  • No vendor money: we take no vendor money, no affiliate links, no paid placements and no sponsored reviews.
  • Vendors can send us facts. They never write or approve our copy.
  • Review-site star averages and vendor marketing are never inputs to a score.
  • The method is public in full on this page, so anyone can check how a score was built.

We don’t name individual testers or show photos. The proof is the method and the record: the plan tested, the test setup, the test date and the tester, the YSMS Lab Test Team.

How do re-tests, versions and disputes work?

Every score shows its method version and test date, and every tool is re-tested on a fixed schedule.

WhatWhen
Full re-test of every item and experience scoreEvery 12 months per tool
Experience scores (parts 6 to 9)Reviewed every 6 months with new studio feedback
Contract terms (part 9)Re-scored when a vendor’s contract terms change
Early re-testAfter a major product release, a change of owner company, or 3 or more studios reporting the same new problem
Re-test schedule

The method is version 3.0. A wording fix that changes no score raises the second number. A change to the parts, weights, rubric, caps or category formulas raises the first number. When the version changes, all 7 tools are recomputed from their stored scores. If a place or a category winner changes, each affected page gets a dated correction note.

Vendors can dispute a finding. To do it, contact us with the facts. We re-check the item within 30 days and add a dated note to the page saying what we checked. The “Last tested” date on a review changes only after a real re-test.

What are the limits of our method?

The method has 6 limits we want you to know about. Here is each one, and what we do about it.

  • There is no Owner Score yet. It needs 30 or more verified owner responses, and the survey has not opened. Until then, every verdict rests on our tests alone.
  • One model studio. Every tool is tested on one setup, an established studio with one location. A studio unlike ours will weigh some parts differently. The supporting scores for new studios, many locations and trainings help here.
  • Experience scores are judgement. Support, migration, data export and contract terms rest on our team’s judgement against written levels, not on a large sample. We publish those levels and review the scores every 6 months.
  • Scores are a snapshot. Each score shows the tool on its test date, and software changes. That is why every score carries its method version and test date, and why we re-test on a schedule.
  • Price counts only through terms. Contract and cost terms shape part 9. Published prices themselves don’t change the Lab Score. Real costs live in our cost guide.
  • Category winners are a call. Scores guide each pick, but YSMS Lab makes the final decision. When a winner is not the top score, its page shows the top 3 scores so you can judge the margin.

Questions owners ask about our scores

Do vendors pay to be reviewed?

No. YSMS Lab takes no money from vendors: no affiliate links, no paid placements and no sponsored reviews. Vendors can send facts, but they never write or approve our copy.

Why is a tool with fewer features ranked higher?

Because features are only 58% of the Lab Score. The other 42% is support, migration, data export and contract terms. A feature-rich tool can lose points on those, or hit a hard cap. Mindbody scores 10.0 on daily scheduling, but it is capped at 5.9 for data and exit terms.

Does a cheaper tool get a higher score?

Only through part 9. Price and contract terms is 14% of the score, and cost is one input to it. Whether a vendor publishes its prices does not change the Lab Score.

Can a vendor get its score changed?

Only with facts. A vendor can dispute a finding, and we re-check the item within 30 days. If the score changes, the page gets a dated note.

Why don’t you use Capterra or G2 star ratings?

Review counts vary too much. On Capterra they range from about 2,990 reviews for Mindbody to 26 for Walla (October 2026). Owner reviews helped set our weights, but star averages are never used in any score.

How often do you re-test each tool?

Every 12 months, with experience scores reviewed every 6 months. A major release, a new owner company or 3 or more studios reporting the same new problem triggers an earlier re-test.

When will Owner Scores appear?

When 30 or more verified owners have rated a tool. Until then, reviews show the Lab Score only, and Owner Scores are never blended into it.

Corrections: none yet. Any correction to this page will be listed here with its date.